Genuine or Fake

When Martin Fischer arrives at his desk in the Regional Council of Stuttgart early in the morning, there are usually several suspicious ID cards already waiting for his trained eye. They have been confiscated by the police in their night checks for Fischer to examine their authenticity. A year ago, the Chief Detective Superintendant qualified as a certified expert on certificate forgeries, fulfilling a professional aim that is perfect for his technical bent.

"Anything serving as a document, whether printed, signed or sealed on paper, plastic or metal – a car registration plate, for instance – that constitutes an authorization or that can be forged to gain advantages, can land on my desk", says Fischer. "To detect professional forgeries and to furnish watertight evidence for my appraisals, I have to keep up with the latest technology." He knows all the document production techniques from traditional printing to the RFID chip and the new security criteria for ID cards.

ID cards and driving licenses from all over the world account for roughly 80 per cent of his work, followed by birth certificates and proof of nationality. But there are plenty of strange and exotic cases, as well. "I recently had a German certificate from a foreign Goethe Institute to examine. Another unusual assignment was to check whether A-level math exam papers had been corrected afterwards to raise the quota", Fischer recounts.

"But my strangest case to date was a Senegalese single status certificate – a long, narrow strip of paper with a sort of writing I had never seen before. Before I can make any kind of statement, I am faced with the challenge of finding out what a document of that type is supposed to look like."

Although there is a personal story behind many certificate forgeries, or the verdict on a defendant may depend on Fischer’s report, he always approaches cases with scientific rigor. "I don’t read the circumstances of the case until I have provided the results, so that I can carry out the examinations in a neutral and unbiased way", stresses the expert.

Even experts like Fischer never fail to be amazed by the skilled and professional way counterfeiters operate today. ID cards and passports (as well as banknotes) are furnished with the highest security standards. Yet the more high-tech features an ID card has been given, the more the counterfeiters upgrade their equipment, and may even try to forge RFID chips, holograms and microtext or to imitate special printing techniques such as iris or intaglio printing or laser engraving. "Nevertheless", says Fischer, "counterfeiters never master all the security features equally well. They usually concentrate on a few particularly prominent features and put a lot of technology into attempts to perfectly reproduce them.

However, they then make amateurish mistakes with other features, and that makes it easier for me to catch them out. A common trick is to stick in holograms, chips or other components from genuine ID cards. These collages are not always easy to detect with the naked eye or by running a finger over them – depending on the skill of the counterfeiter."

The first step in every new case is always to classify the document as authentic or fictitious. If Fischer does not recognize the type of document, he searches in databases for a reference sample. The second step is to check for obvious signs of manipulation. His trained eye and sense of touch detect major signs of manipulation immediately, for example if stamps have been rubbed out, numbers overwritten by hand or a new photo inserted in an amateurish way. This is followed by examination under a microscope. "I couldn’t do this job without a good microscope. Most cases are decided during the microscopic examination", Fischer says. He works with the high-performance stereomicroscope Leica M165 C which has a 16.5:1 zoom and features LED right light, flexible LED fiber optic guide, a mobile swivel arm, a high-definition camera and a full HD monitor.

"The combination of good illumination and the 3D impression of the stereomicroscope are critically important for examining the finest details of the document’s surface structure. The details of better forgeries only show up under the microscope – for instance, attempts to imitate laser engraving, gravure or relief printing elements, or good collages where the chip, hologram or serial number, etc. have been added afterwards. There are always discrepancies somewhere – at the edges, the transitions of fine linear printing patterns, or the orientation of the paper fibers", Fischer explains.

If only the photo has been exchanged, and this has been carefully done, typographic examinations or data readouts do not provide any useful information. The only way to find clues is under the microscope. Sometimes, Fischer bends the ID card over the edge of the table to look under the edge of the photo that has been stuck in. If he finds torn fibers on the side of the ID card that do not correspond to the back of the photo, the case is clear.

"A false photo is still the most common way of manipulating ID cards", says Fischer. "With good forgeries it’s not always easy to find the clues. This is where I use the highest magnifications of the microscope. For basic examinations, the low zoom range between 20 and 30x is usually adequate."

Apart from the microscope, Fischer also uses other instruments, e.g. to examine certain security features,  inks or stamp dyes under UV or IR light or to read out the personal data of the chip.

At the end of every examination, Fischer documents his results. His appraisal also includes the photos of the microscope images with thorough annotations. "I naturally take care to formulate the report in such a way that there are no outstanding issues", Fischer stresses. "I am rarely summoned to attend court proceedings to explain my reasons for an appraisal."